SC Verdict: Moral support to Uddhav, legal support to Shinde

Supreme Court

Rama Krishna Sangem

The Supreme Court’s five member Constitution bench headed by Chief Justice DY Chandrachud on May 11, Thursday gave moral solace to Shiv Sena’s deposed CM Uddhav Thackeray and gave legal validity to rebel Sen leader and CM Eknath Shinde. This is an interesting judgement by SC in recent times. Going by various analyses, it appears, this will lead to more litigation, if not confusion, in the days to come. There are many contradictory points too in it.

Other four justices on the bench are: MR Shah, Krishna  Murari, Hima Kohli and PS Narasimha. Everyone, including political parties, eagerly waited for a year for this judgement. All expected two outcomes – validating Shinde becoming CM or reinstating Uddhav as CM again. The first thing has happened, but the thrust of the judgment is fully in support of Uddhav. Of  course, this is moral support, not legal support he expected.

The apex court went to the extent of saying it would have reinstated Uddhav as CM, had he not resigned before taking the floor test. But, refrained from doing so, because, Shinde was appointed CM by then Governor Bhagat Singh Koshari subsequently. At the same time, the court found fault with the Governor for calling for a floor test after receiving a letter of distrust from Shinde group of Sena MLAs.

The verdict said, the Governor need not call for a floor test just because some MLAs express dissatisfaction against their leadership. The Governor should objectively verify the actual situation. But, there are SC judgments, particularly in case of Karnataka, which say, Raj Bhavans (Governor offices) are not the venues, but the floor of the assembly should be the places to decide whether a government enjoys majority or not. So, a floor test is the best solution.


Supremacy of Party

The top court in many ways says that the party leadership is the right authority to appoint a Whip or issue directions to the legislators, not the leader of the legislature party. There are some contradictory rulings earlier  – in case of the then CM NTR’s removal of CM, the court upheld rebel ladear Chandrababu Naidu’s power to appoint a whip. Naidu continued as CM after the court judgment.

In Maharashtra, the SC ruled that assembly speaker RahuNarwekar should now verify who among – Uddhav and Shinde  – command majority MLAs and recognize their authority. Narwekar, a BJP MLA, would do the job, obviously in favour of Shinde. So, Uddhav Thackeray will again go to SC challenging the order. This indicates to a prolonged legal battle in the corridors of apex court.

There is a view that the top court has not taken note of the developments of Indian democracy, where political parties are held in tight grip of some established leaderships over decades. Whoever wants to rebel will not success, if SC ruling is applied in letter and spirit. If this becomes the rule, it goes against to the spirit of democracy. Constant changes and alignments and realignments are part of democracy. The SC judgment fell short on this emerging situations.


Rama Krishna Sangem

Ramakrishna chief editor of excel India online magazine and website

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Post

Pakistan Supreme Court asserts, grants bail to Imran

Fri May 12 , 2023
Rama Krishna Sangem Pakistan Supreme Court has asserted itself and granted two weeks bail to arrested Former Prime Minister Imran Khan in a corruption case […]
Arrest of Imran Khan

You May Like

Chief Editor

Rama Krishna Sangem

Excel India national news magazine is a media startup founded and piloted by Rama Krishna Sangem, a Hyderabad based senior journalist with over three decade experience in the field of media, mostly in print journalism. His rich experience in reporting for both Telugu and English newspapers and heading a TV news channel and some online outfits will be of immense use to this venture. Excel India English news magazine seeks to fill the gap of analytical understanding to our readers who today are confronted with myriad media platforms. Our online version not only offers regular updates and commentary on happenings around us, but also gives larger stories not limited by space constraints of a print magazine. Excel India is ably run by a team of senior journalists committed to values and quality standards in the profession. We urge you all to support and guide us in this endeavour. Reach us at